Glenlivet 15 y.o.
This one had some slight urine-y undertones when first tasted. Once it settles in, though, it's pretty decent. Overall, I'd give it 3/5. I expected better, given the price.Dimple Pinch 15 y.o.
Not bad. Reminds me of JW Black. At least it's cheap. 3.5/5.